Mafia Game 1: Game Over - Town Wins! (4,772 views)

[20s]

Ok, well it’s 7-3 now with both our power roles intact.

Would be a good idea to hit on the vote today.

[Dirt]

Soup still alive hmmm. Sus

[bankz]

Jan 12, 2021 21:02:45 GMT -5 Dirt said:

Soup still alive hmmm. Sus

why

[Dirt]

His Charisma is off the charts. IF i was mafia he be whacked first go. Ank was a non-participant easy kill

[bankz]

JHB is also a very strong player. You would think mafia would want to kill him.

[Deleted]

we're already in some weird timeline where i am alive day 2 so anything is possible

[Soup]

Jan 12, 2021 20:50:07 GMT -5 20s said:

Ok, well it’s 7-3 now with both our power roles intact.

Would be a good idea to hit on the vote today.

Good thing WE HAD TO VOTE SOMEONE OFF day 1. Ridiculous.

[Soup]

the most likely scenario if you vote someone off day one is 7-3 town advantage after night one. i think 20s is town but i cant believe he was pushing so hard for that scenario and refused to see it any other way.

[delap]

I'll gather my thoughts for the morning, but my gut tells me that Skrouse's late switch to NO EXECUTION seems like a mafioso hiding in a safe place. I would expect that the 3 Mafia ended up on 3 separate vote outcomes on Day 1.

[delap]

And I'm headed to bed.

[20s]

What do we think of trofie coming off his DaChap vote to kill pointy? His original vote wasn’t even part of the 3 way tie which happened at the end when vanilla civ pointyegg voted JHB to protect himself. Was trofie trying to make sure JHB didn’t die? Ankly was one of the other JHB voters along with pointyegg and myself. Trofie hasn’t voted for any of the 3, then switched to pointyegg instead of either no execution or JHB.

[20s]

Jan 12, 2021 21:36:03 GMT -5 Soup said:

the most likely scenario if you vote someone off day one is 7-3 town advantage after night one. i think 20s is town but i cant believe he was pushing so hard for that scenario and refused to see it any other way.

And the most likely scenario if you don’t vote someone off day one is a 6-3 town advantage day two. 

You know I’m a numbers guy, and I heard once that you should always execute on day one to give yourselves the best chance to win, and I’m too lazy to go look up if that holds true with two power roles on the town side. 

[20s]

6-3 town on day 3, typo

[Dirt]

Yea i'm not sure why Trofie would change his vote. It really doesn't do anything for us citizens. If he was a PI like he claimed why not allow the random kill? He could Investigate Pointy if he stayed.

[Deleted]

alright well Compuhunches says 20s is mafia

p.s. remember when 20s actually thought i had analyzed his posts with machine learning and was able to tell if he was mafia

this time i can just tell because of how dirty all his posting is. maybe he isn't mafia but i don't think anyone is a more likely mafia.

p.p.s. note the slight difference between "mafia" and "gangster", because dachapparals is 100% gangster

[20s]

You’re entitled to your opinion.

[bankz]

I can’t understand this fucker

[Deleted]

i could possibly switch my vote later, usually someone drops some real good insight that becomes obvious to go along with, but until then i just feel like 20s has acted the most suspicious so far. not sure what we would have after 1 night though. fwiw I'm generally no execution day 1 so I don't like piling onto the votes early. It's good however to get a lot of people to record their votes (and even switch a few times each day for XTRA info) because when someone finally dies that pops up mafia it's usually pretty telling

[Deleted]

also ive been drinking tonight, i'll stop now and wait for tomorrow

[jhb]

Wow compuhunches has made an assessment

How do we feel about trophy saying he’s detective/sheriff/investigator/whatever that role is called

[Chaps]

Trofie needs to investigate himself to really see whats goin on

[skrouse]

Sorry fellas, busy afternoon/evening and busy night, will try to contribute a bit more in the early am

[delap]

Good amount of evidence of weirdness with Pointy, but I slept on it and still feel skrouse is just off. I can be convinced otherwise, though.

[Druce]

Jan 12, 2021 22:42:07 GMT -5 jhb said:

Wow compuhunches has made an assessment

How do we feel about trophy saying he’s detective/sheriff/investigator/whatever that role is called

couple thoughts. it definitely ensures that he makes it through night 1 and gets to investigate someone if thats true because the mafia would have to be dumb to try and whack him knowing a bg is in the game on the flip side, it also ensures a successful mafia hit on night one in the likely scenario that bg protects him, they obviously can't protect anyone else. i would love to hear from trofie as to what the strategy was in making that announcement. off the top of my head i dont particularly recall a push for trofie to be killed day 1 and i honestly don't see him as a likely mafia target night 1 so the motivation to come forward unprompted as investigator seems a bit shaky

[delap]

** I meant to say Trofie, not Pointy, in my post above

[skrouse]

Jan 13, 2021 7:52:02 GMT -5 delap said:

Good amount of evidence of weirdness with Pointy, but I slept on it and still feel skrouse is just off. I can be convinced otherwise, though.

That's fair, but I would say it's more because I missed half of the game yesterday and didn't want my low activity to seem sus.  For example, I 100% missed the whole trofie acting like he was the PI until JHB pointed it out.  But I don't mind going if it helps us get more info.

[jhb]

Is there anyone else that can override trofie's claim?

Can Trofie at least come in and tell us what he knows since the cat's already out of the bag. We can at least clear 2 people if he'll let us know what he's learned today and tomorrow.

[delap]

I didn't take Trofie seriously yesterday. I'm not sure I'll take him seriously today.

[20s]

I’m going to vote JHB again right now because:

• List item 1
• List item 2
• List item 3

[20s]

Well you can see I fucked up the formatting on those bullet points but I can’t edit.