Mafia Game 6 Thread - Day 1 Ends 3/30 12pm EST (1,269 views)

[Odin]

if we're burning shit down lets start with tree aka sapular

[Sapular]

That would not be a wise move

[Handsome Pete]

Mar 29, 2021 21:05:21 GMT -5 Sapular said:

That would not be a wise move

Hmmm....mafia members are often called wise guys. so if it's not a wise move, then that must mean it's in the interest of town

[Sapular]

Mar 29, 2021 21:28:20 GMT -5 Handsome Pete said:

Mar 29, 2021 21:05:21 GMT -5 Sapular said:

That would not be a wise move

Hmmm....mafia members are often called wise guys. so if it's not a wise move, then that must mean it's in the interest of town

Fair point.  It would not be in the towns best interest to kill me off

[Soup]

I’ll buy in to bk giving his buddy mafia role.

chap

[Odin]

pretty sure that the right move day 1 is always no kill because theres no evidence whatsoever to base any kill on. but thats true for all mafia kills so...

[Chaps]

My early read, based on much evidence, is that Timpig and Soup have formed some sort of votingmafia cartel.

[TinyTimPig]

Mar 29, 2021 22:08:03 GMT -5 Chaps said:

My early read, based on much evidence, is that Timpig and Soup have formed some sort of votingmafia cartel.

Go and listen to my 20-minute anti-cartel rant and then come back and accuse me of joining one.

[Chaps]

Well ok then Tim, I'm also very anti-cartel. I don't want them dangerous caravans coming across the sim-mexico/sim-texas border. But we're never going to accomplish anything if we are fighting amongst ourselves.

[gbgalla24]

With two potential sheriffs out there, I'm going with No execution unless I see something tomorrow morning that convinces me otherwise.

[skrouse]

Mar 29, 2021 22:40:48 GMT -5 gbgalla24 said:

With two potential sheriffs out there, I'm going with No execution unless I see something tomorrow morning that convinces me otherwise.

I think I agree. It's 8-4 to start, if we miss day one after the Maf hit it goes to 6-4. Not sure how we come back from that.

[skrouse]

No Execution

[jhb]

Starting a game at 7pm and then ending the first day at 10am EST is super tight, great move BK

[jhb]

Mar 30, 2021 7:02:13 GMT -5 skrouse said:

Mar 29, 2021 22:40:48 GMT -5 gbgalla24 said:

With two potential sheriffs out there, I'm going with No execution unless I see something tomorrow morning that convinces me otherwise.

I think I agree. It's 8-4 to start, if we miss day one after the Maf hit it goes to 6-4. Not sure how we come back from that.

I would agree with this logic if it were correct, but we have 14 players so the game would be 8-4 after two kills if they're both civs.

[skrouse]

Mar 30, 2021 7:25:25 GMT -5 jhb said:

Mar 30, 2021 7:02:13 GMT -5 skrouse said:

I think I agree. It's 8-4 to start, if we miss day one after the Maf hit it goes to 6-4. Not sure how we come back from that.

I would agree with this logic if it were correct, but we have 14 players so the game would be 8-4 after two kills if they're both civs.

Oh 14 not 12, thought it felt tilted a little heavy toward the maf. 

So 10-4 to 8-4 if we miss on a vote day 1. I think I'm still good with no exec

[gbgalla24]

We only have 6 votes in so far... people need to start voting or BK needs to extend the day, imo.

[gbgalla24]

Trofie
20s
@zaddypete
delap
@el chapo
bankz
jhb

[gbgalla24]

Vote count:

No execution - 3 (Skrouse, GBG, Odin)
Chap - 2 (Tim, Soup)
Pete - 1 (Ank)


Not voted: Pete, 20s, JHB, sapular, Bankz, Delap, Trofie, Chap

[Chaps]

So I work today, can only check in on occasion. This will likely be my vote for today, for good, I can't change before class starts.

I'm going with TimPig, his reasoning for voting me is sketchy.

[delap]

oh hey. good morning.

[bankz]

Lots of active players are laying low. Not sure if it’s the rushed start or new strategy...

My vote is 20s

[delap]

no kill to allow our boys in blue to do their work.

if you vote to kill you must not BACK THE BLUE

[Soup]

yeah, kind of an early day 1 deadline but it is what it is at this point. Don't think we'll get much of a read on day 1 with so many people not even voting yet. It might be worth it to get a majority so people dont get penalized for missing a vote.

[Odin]

Mar 30, 2021 7:58:22 GMT -5 Soup said:

yeah, kind of an early day 1 deadline but it is what it is at this point. Don't think we'll get much of a read on day 1 with so many people not even voting yet. It might be worth it to get a majority so people dont get penalized for missing a vote.

its mafia, theres no way to actually read anything. its just random people yelling about random executions with no evidence outside of investigations.

[delap]

Mar 30, 2021 8:06:39 GMT -5 Odin said:

Mar 30, 2021 7:58:22 GMT -5 Soup said:

yeah, kind of an early day 1 deadline but it is what it is at this point. Don't think we'll get much of a read on day 1 with so many people not even voting yet. It might be worth it to get a majority so people dont get penalized for missing a vote.

its mafia, theres no way to actually read anything. its just random people yelling about random executions with no evidence outside of investigations.

this, on day 1, is especially true

[Deleted]

Time extended to 12pm EST (2 extra hours). Having to go into work unexpectedly.

[Sapular]

I agree that a No Execution is the best play here.

[Soup]

Mar 30, 2021 8:08:09 GMT -5 delap said:

Mar 30, 2021 8:06:39 GMT -5 Odin said:

its mafia, theres no way to actually read anything. its just random people yelling about random executions with no evidence outside of investigations.

this, on day 1, is especially true

meh, we learned a lot after day 1 of last game. I can't help if the town wouldn't follow the bread crumbs

[Soup]

Mar 30, 2021 8:10:45 GMT -5 @jayz93j said:

Time extended to 12pm EST (2 extra hours). Having to go into work unexpectedly.

Thank you. This will work out better i think. 

[Handsome Pete]

no kill

Will be in meetings today through around 3 so won't be able to participate much today